Best Broadway Shows to See on a New York City Break

Broadway in New York

There is nothing quite like seeing a Broadway show in New York. The lights, the theatres, the energy of Times Square and that feeling when the curtain goes up all make it one of the most iconic things to do in the city.

Whether it is your first time in New York or your tenth, building a trip around a Broadway show is always a good idea. It gives your city break a proper main event, with dinner, drinks and a night in Midtown all part of the experience.

This summer, Paramount Times Square - A Generator Hotel is making it easier to plan your theatre trip with the Midweek Marquee Menu Broadway Stay Package. The package includes a stay at Paramount Times Square, weekday matinee tickets for two and post-show cocktails back at the hotel.

Not sure which show to choose? Here is a guide to the three Broadway picks included in the package.

SIX on Broadway

If you want a Broadway show with high energy, big vocals and a soundtrack that stays in your head, SIX is the one.

The show reimagines the six wives of Henry VIII as pop stars, giving each queen her own moment to tell her story. It is bold, fast-paced and full of personality, with the feel of a live concert and the polish of a Broadway musical.

SIX is a great choice if you are travelling with friends, planning a fun city break or want a show that feels modern, punchy and easy to love. It is also a strong option if you want the Broadway experience without choosing something too traditional.

Best for: friends, first-time Broadway visitors, pop music fans and anyone who wants a fun, high-energy show.

Operation Mincemeat on Broadway

Operation Mincemeat is the choice for anyone who loves clever comedy, sharp writing and a show that feels a little different.

Based on the unbelievable true story of a World War II deception operation, the musical mixes history, humour and unexpected heart. It is witty, fast-moving and full of character, making it a strong pick for theatre fans who want something smart but still fun.

This is the kind of show that keeps surprising you. It has the pace of a comedy, the shape of a thriller and songs that make the story even more memorable.

Best for: comedy lovers, theatre lovers, history fans and anyone who wants something original.

Two Strangers on Broadway

Two Strangers, also known as Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York), is perfect if you want a show with charm, humour and a real New York feel.

The story follows two strangers brought together in the city, with awkward moments, quick dialogue and feel-good energy along the way. It is warm, funny and easy to connect with, especially if you like shows that lean into romance, personality and city adventure.

Because the story is set around New York, it is a lovely choice for a Broadway trip. You get to watch a city story while actually being in the city, which makes the whole experience feel even more special.

Best for: couples, rom-com fans, New York first-timers and anyone who wants a feel-good show.

Why Stay at Paramount Times Square

If Broadway is part of your New York plan, staying near Times Square makes everything easier.

Paramount Times Square puts you close to the Theatre District, so you can spend less time travelling across the city and more time enjoying it. Broadway theatres, restaurants, bars, late-night food spots and some of Midtown Manhattan’s most famous sights are all within easy reach.

Paramount also has its own New York story. The hotel has been part of Times Square since 1928, with a long connection to the city’s theatre and entertainment scene. You can read more in our article on the history of Paramount Times Square.

For a Broadway trip, the location is the main win. Explore during the day, head to your matinee, then come back to Paramount for cocktails after the show. Simple, central and very New York.

Plan More of Your New York Trip

Broadway can be the reason you book the trip, but it does not have to be the only thing you do. Staying at Paramount Times Square keeps you close to Midtown, museums, restaurants, nightlife and easy subway connections across the city.

If you want to add more culture to your stay, check out our guide to 5 museums near Paramount Times Square. For sports fans, our US Open tennis guide covers everything you need to know about planning a New York trip around the tournament. You can also explore the New York World Cup 2026 match schedule if you are visiting for a major sporting event.

Book Your Broadway Stay

If you are planning a New York city break, the Midweek Marquee Menu Broadway Stay Package brings together everything you need for an easy theatre escape.

Choose your show, enjoy your stay and toast the night with cocktails after the curtain call.